The Failure of the Einstein-Lorentz Spherical Wave Proof

Posted by Steven Bryant On March - 23 - 2010


The Failure of the Einstein-Lorentz Spherical Wave Proof
(Click to download)


This paper reveals a subtle, yet extremely significant oversight in Einstein’s Spherical Wave Proof. Once identified and corrected, it also shows that the proof fails, which means that Einstein cannot establish the relationship between the constancy of the speed of light and the principle of relativity.


Einstein’s transformation equations are believed to be mathematically correct in part due to the Spherical Wave Proof that Einstein offers in each of his derivations. Einstein asserts that if an electromagnetic wave is propagated as a Sphere in system K that the wave will also be represented as a Sphere in system K’, where the values of the Sphere in K’ are determined using the transformation equations. The proof asserts a one-to-one mapping between the points representing the Sphere in K and the points representing the Sphere in K’. Here we find that Einstein’s proof shows that the transformed values conform to the general equation of a Sphere in K’, but that his proof does not validate that all of the transformed points are part of the same Sphere in K’. We then show that the proof fails because the transformed K’ values have different radiuses and represent points on multiple spheres in K’, instead of on a single sphere.


  • Created: March 2010
  • Last Revised: April 16, 2010
  • Publication Status:  Prepared for Conference Proceedings, NPA Conference, CSU Long Beach 2010

Comments are closed.